I would play some great covers, of bands playing other band's songs, of varying genres (mainly pop punk and such). I would play songs by the original bands then the covered versions, and talk about them. Then I would also cover songs live with my acoustic guitar and vocals, and bring guest musicians in to do covers on my show.
Ho Ho Hopefully
The Maine
I Won't Be Home for Christmas
Blink 182
Nothing for Christmas
New Found Glory
Sleigh ride
This Wild Life
Merry Christmas, Kiss My Ass
All Time Low
Mr. Winter
The Maine
O holy night
Go Radio
30 Days
Never Shout Never
Santa Stole My Girlfriend
The Maine
All i want for christmas is you
Against The Current
winter wonderland/here comes santa clause
Snoop Dogg and Anna Kendrick
12 Days of a Pop-Punk Christmas
Jarrod Alonge
The Chanukah Song
Adam Sandler
Can I Introduce You In Hanukkah?
Stephen Colbert and Jon Stewart
Last Christmas (Wham! Cover)
The Maine
You're A Mean One Mr Grinch
VersaEmerge
Fool's Holiday
All Time Low
o holy night
Hey Monday
all i want for christmas
My Chemical Romance
Yule Shoot Your Eye Out (Bonus Track)
Fall out Boy